SUPERSTAR vs. NON SUPERSTAR

So I was looking through the shops and I found this shop Piviera and the very first dress I saw looked like items you could put together in Basics. So I thought it's kind of like a superstar version? Here are the snapshots.

So here is the non superstar version, I personally think  it is beautiful.  What do you think?

This here is the superstar version, I love this one too, but you know, they're both the same so, yeah.